All of Devin_Finbarr's Comments + Replies

Devin, as awful as democracy is, I don't see any reason to doubt the verdict of history that monarchy is worse. Important question: Are Congressional staff brighter than the actual Congresspeople?

Are you aware that the victors write the history? Pick up a Chinese history book and you'll read about what a swell guy Mao was. Sure some things he did were a bit suboptimal, but in general, he was a great man that was a blessing for China. The United States has a $1 trillion state education system. What kind of myths has it have filled your head with?

If you ... (read more)

3taryneast
You've only talked about transitions (which are always bloody) and fallout from transitions , while people adjust. I'd rather hear about the actual differences in living conditions under the different political systems once they've stabilised. I don't know enough about it, but it might be interesting to compare living conditions of Rome under democratic rule vs during the years of empire.
1Luke Allen
It makes me think a republic is the best form of governance possible among humans, as long as the real smarties are running the show and they have good priors. Real smarties with bad priors may be worse than average successful achievers with good priors.
gwern271

It wouldn't change mine much. The point is that all these people were pretty much selected, and not born to it.

Now, it does make me wonder about the Chinese mandarins...

This is very true. When I first interned Congress, I was amazed that everyone who worked there was several cuts above the median in intelligence. Plus, most people were genuinely dedicated and well intentioned. Even many of the lobbyists honestly believed that they were just trying to ensure that the business they worked for got its fair share.

The reason things go wrong, I believe, is the process of Adaptive Fiction. ( see http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2007/07/democracy-as-adaptive-fiction.html ). Let's say you have 100 very smart peopl... (read more)

7Ben Pace
(aka "Selection effect")