All of FullMeta_Rationalist's Comments + Replies

Disclaimer: I'm no economist. This discussion is getting out of my comfort zone, so I skimmed wikipedia. I recommend you do likewise (and maybe browse a library). Here are my two cents anyway.

So is real-estate rent-seeking? How is it different from domain sharking?

In your draft, I think you're confusing distribution with land-development with ownership.

  • A Real-Estate Agent facilitates exchange. They create a market by matching buyers to sellers. They are valuable middlemen because buying and selling real estate would be more difficult otherwise.

  • A

... (read more)
1Adam Zerner
Thank you. Your comments have been very helpful!

How do you know when no value is being created?

You ask who benefits not from the trade, but from the agent's existence. Let's reason counterfactually: what would the market look like if the restaurant were removed from the equation?

  1. If the restaurant is profitable and popular, then customers will feel sad over its absence.

  2. If the restaurant is unprofitable and unpopular, then removing the restaurant won't make much difference (and free up resources to be allocated elsewhere).

  3. If the restaurant redistributes storebought merchandise where it otherwi

... (read more)
0Adam Zerner
Thanks! The idea to reason counter-factually is very helpful. 1) So is real-estate rent-seeking? How is it different from domain sharking? 2) What allows someone to extract rent? The only things I could think of are a) governmental power, b) ownership rights, and maybe c) physical force. 3) Are there degrees of rent-seeking? Like what if a domain shark is using the domain to host a site that has tetris, and a few of his friends play it? Is that still technically rent-seeking? What if 100 people played it? 1,000? 1,000,000? Is rent-seeking relative to what it could have been (like would it be rent-seeking if the domain could have been used by google or something?)? This is my understanding of rent-seeking. If you wouldn't mind, I'd appreciate any comments/elaborations. No worries at all if you don't want to.
max( Candy / e^Walking ) 

fudged with a constant of proportionality (pun intended).

I was confused too. Not only by "did he mean video game?", but also "how does he define sales?".

I picked Super Mario Bros and called it a day.

FINISHED. ALL OF IT. \m/ Literally superhuman.

TIL I'm undifferentiated according to the BSRI... huh.

Karma for all, per tradition. <3

- a long time lurker

P.S. You can trashcan the premature submission that answers Part 8's first question with 23200. While revising my predicted date of the singularity, I brushed my keypad's enter (next to the 3) by mistake. ಠ_ಠ

Cyan130

Nice choice of username. :-)