All of Kallandras's Comments + Replies

I've recently begun listening to a few bands that are new to me - Parov Stelar, Tape Five, Caravan Palace, and Goldfish. I have found the upbeat tempo of electro-swing to be helpful when I want to improve my mood.

My interpretation of your Gears-ness tracks well with the degree to which prior beliefs are interrelated.

Interrelatedness of prior beliefs is useful because it allows for rapid updating on limited information. If I visit another world and find that matches don't work, for example, I will begin investigating all sorts of other chemical interactions and question how the hell I'm deriving energy, as clearly oxygen doesn't work the way I think it does any more. I'll re-evaluate every related prior.

An unrelated prior belief acts like a single gear - an update... (read more)

4Valentine
Yep, that seems right to me. I'm a bit bugged by (my and maybe your) lack of Gears around what's meant by "interrelated", but yeah, this matches my impressions. I like the explicit connection to priors. I'm reminded of this from HPMOR chapter 2:
0ChristianKl
I think there's a minimum amount of karma you need for it.

My perspective is that religious folk have not been prepping the party. Scientists have been trying to get some instruments together to make some music, but the religious people keep grabbing guitars, smashing them, and calling it music. Then, when the music finally starts up despite all the smashed instruments, religious folks say "oh hey, that's what we were trying to do, you're welcome everybody."

As soon as something conveniently fits the religious narrative (appropriately tortured beyond its original construction), it gets incorporated. I find that frustrating, as it should instead shatter the narrative and reveal it for the useless pile of dogma that it is.

1eternal_neophyte
Most scientists are not extropian in any sense - so if they have been "prepping the party" it was not deliberate. Are you considering scientists and religious folk as disjoint sets?

Will the machine deity require you to accept Christ as your savior before letting you become a transhuman? No? Then why the hell is that written in the bronze age book that you claim knowingly predicted this outcome?

The classic idea of heaven looks like a post-scarcity, post-death society because that's what we've always imagined would be nice. It's not divine prophecy, just something common to humanity, and we've done a lot of ignoring religious "answers" to get there. I resent that religious people would try to co-opt all this work and at this late date contemplate the idea of a digital entity with a "soul."

2Oscar_Cunningham
This is a good point. It's hardly surprising that the utopia we fantasise about is the same as the one we try to create.
4Gordon Seidoh Worley
At the risk of being rude, this sounds more like your problems than theirs. I'm not sure religious transhumanists are even that late to the party: we happen to be part of a community that got there very early and has been slowly prepping the party so it'll be ready when folks arrive. Maybe religious folks want to dance to different music than we do and you might find that annoying, but is that better than no one showing up to the party at all? And if we don't like it we can always go hang out in a room upstairs for a while without leaving, because the music will eventually change. It always does.
0g_pepper
The New Testament is not really a bronze age book. Wikipedia states that the bronze age ended in the near east region around 1200 BC.

The improvement in human productivity would be substantial, just in terms of the time saved while not driving, not to mention the extra man-hours from people not dying in preventable collisions.

I've also been thinking that it could cause a big shakeup in the housing market, as living in suburbs would be more appealing when your hour-long commute is reading/working time instead of driving time.

0username2
You mean living in suburbs is not appealing? ;)

You'd never get the million that way, there's a greater-than-zero chance that you'll die before making a decision.

0Good_Burning_Plastic
Okay, make that "with probability greater than 99.95%".