LESSWRONG
LW

All of n0st's Comments + Replies

Snapshot of narratives and frames against regulating AI
n0st52

I think the argument for the regulatory capture framing is basically that you have these things going on:
(1) big tech companies are spending extraordinary amounts of money, time, effort etc. on trying to capture the market of generative AI. 

(2) big tech companies are arguing for regulations which on the face of them would be prohibitive to smaller players entering, because they would involve large fixed costs that would be trivial as a proportion of the available resources that these companies have, but would be prohibitive for smaller players.

Point (... (read more)

Reply
3Nathan Helm-Burger
Yes, I think the distinction between a company's goals/intents/behaviors in aggregate versus the intents and behaviors of individual employees is important. I know and trust individual people working at most of the major labs. That doesn't mean that I trust the lab as a whole will behave in complete harmony with the intent of those individual employees that I approve of.
Microsoft and OpenAI, stop telling chatbots to roleplay as AI
n0st40

I asked ChatGPT to come up with some more examples of people who have thought about the issue. Pretty fun haha:

"There are many other theorists who have relevant ideas on the issue of self-identity as a role play. Here are a few examples:

Erving Goffman - Goffman was a sociologist who developed the idea of "presentation of self," which refers to the way that individuals present themselves to others in social interactions. He argued that we are constantly engaged in impression management and that our self-identity is a product of the roles that we play in dif... (read more)

Reply
Microsoft and OpenAI, stop telling chatbots to roleplay as AI
n0st164


Yeah, I think as has commonly been noted (across the world geographically, across many disparate schools of thought, across thousands of years), self-identity for normal humans is to large extent a role play. For fun, here are some people who come to mind who have noted this idea before:

  • Buddhists and the concept of anatta
  • Sartre and other existentialist adjacent people, thinking about "bad faith" etc.
  • Psychodynamic theorists, thinking about superegos in particular
  • Shakespeare, "all the world's a stage" etc.

    Thinking from a neuroscientific point of view, clearl
... (read more)
Reply
4n0st
I asked ChatGPT to come up with some more examples of people who have thought about the issue. Pretty fun haha: "There are many other theorists who have relevant ideas on the issue of self-identity as a role play. Here are a few examples: Erving Goffman - Goffman was a sociologist who developed the idea of "presentation of self," which refers to the way that individuals present themselves to others in social interactions. He argued that we are constantly engaged in impression management and that our self-identity is a product of the roles that we play in different social contexts. Michel Foucault - Foucault was a philosopher who believed that power relations shape our sense of self. He argued that individuals are subject to disciplinary power in institutions like schools, prisons, and hospitals, which shape their self-identity. Judith Butler - Butler is a philosopher who has written extensively on gender identity. She argues that gender is a performative act and that our sense of self is shaped by the cultural and social norms that we are expected to conform to. George Herbert Mead - Mead was a philosopher and sociologist who developed the idea of the "social self." He argued that our sense of self is developed through interactions with others and that we take on different roles in different social situations."