All of Ollie Sayeed's Comments + Replies

Can you explain why "most democratic Western countries will become fascist dictatorships" specifically is the most likely outcome? I'm not quite following the "line go up" reasoning.

Just to give some concrete illustrations: Western Europe has dropped by 0.08 points on the Democracy Index over the last decade. If that happens again, it will fall to 8.28, so about as democratic as the UK is now. Definitely not fascist dictatorship territory!

If we pessimistically assume that Western Europe will decline faster in line with the world average, we get to 8.13, a ... (read more)

This is called burying. It makes sense in systems that violate the later-no-help or later-no-harm criteria, but instant-runoff voting satisfies both of those.

https://electowiki.org/wiki/Tactical_voting#Burying

I like this framing a lot – thanks for sharing!

Looking forward to it! Will it be on Pocketcasts?

1Quinn
When I submitted to pocketcasts it said we were already on it :) https://pca.st/9froevor

Is ED different to the Coombs method?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coombs%27_method

3abramdemski
Nice find! From the wikipedia article: The first condition, "if at any time one candidate is ranked first by an absolute majority", is different from ED -- I only included the second clause. I'm guessing Coomb's method is probably an improvement in some sense, although I haven't thought through any details yet. But wikipedia also says my variant has been discussed in the literature: Thanks for the pointer!