All of TimK's Comments + Replies

TimK
10

Perhaps our trivial but to us purposeful motions will be fun for ASI to watch and will continue to entertain.

 

This is something I see bandied about at different levels of seriousness, sometimes even as full defense of AI x-risk. But why would an AI experience entertainment? That type of experience in humans is caused by a feedback loop between the brain and the body. Without physical biological bodies to interrupt or interfere with a programmatically defined reward function in that way, the reward function maintains at state indefinitely. 

1ProfessorPublius
"But why would an AI experience entertainment?" I think it's reasonable to assume that AI would build one logical conclusion on another with exceptional rapidity, relative to slower thinkers. Eventually, and probably soon because of its speed, I expect that AI would hit a dead end where it simply doesn't have the facts to add to its already complete analysis of the information it started with plus the information it has collected. In that situation, many people would want entertainment, so we can speculate that maybe AI would want entertainment too. Generalizing from one example is not anywhere near conclusive, but it provides a plausible scenario.
TimK
10

People Would Like a Better Explanation of Why People Are Worried That AI Might Kill Everyone

 

it seems to me like we need a Young Lady’s Illustrated Primer limited to just patiently explaining to the user why AI Ruin. Where a link could be sent along with instructions to just, “Keep talking to this until it makes sense.” Which in turn seems like we absolutely have the technology currently to make,

I’d apply via the common application to develop this, but I only bring the project management skills (haven’t really coded in over 15 years), and I’m not sure how to hire the right programmers anymore, either. 

Answer by TimK
10

This may be a flavor of Novelty.

TimK
10

4b. No, coordinating people is not a hard problem requiring unique solutions each time. Mega-project management is a science with a well-defined vocabulary and structure; there is very definitely a corpus of training data for it. It's also not necessary to know every single detail of any one mega-project in order to implement another one - the phrase "work unit" is used in project management to denote this principle. Your conclusions for this section are built on multiple misconceptions and category errors.

TimK
10

One way of thinking about mutually held exclusive beliefs in general is that in these instances, the person’s map cannot reconcile to a terrain but maps don’t need to.

TimK
20

Perhaps even more clearly would be: Law of the Phrase 'No Evidence'.

Answer by TimK
40

Where I live (USA, Kentucky), we've been under something much like "shelter in place" without the scary name and been engaged in social distancing, event cancellation, bars and restaurants closed, non-life sustaining businesses closed, strongly encouraged work from home, etc., etc. for over a week now. Masks & googles are being strongly encouraged in Kentucky to be crafted, sourced and donated for front-line healthcare and emergency workers plus at-risk populations. We're hearing massive messaging about the grave risks of being indo... (read more)

3Steven Byrnes
I'm very happy to hear that! Here in Massachusetts, we are doing many of the same things. It's just that that list of things somehow never coalesced into a message in my mind: "Don't breathe air that has been recently exhaled by someone else!" as a general principle for guiding my decisions and actions. I have heard "Wash your hands" 5000 times from officials, bosses, celebrities, etc., but I have never once heard that.