All of zyansheep's Comments + Replies

zyansheep5-2

I think I agree with Feynman being a straight talker, but I just want to caution on inferences on Feynman from books about Feynman. See:

TLDW: Feynman didn't actually write any of the books that use his name, and his influence over them is pretty tenuous. (e.g. Surely Your Joking was written by a young friend of Feynman's, and the book wasn't written until like at least 10 years after the stories were originally told, allegedly)

4habryka
I didn't watch the whole video (it's 2 hours long), but like I remember the process by which the books were written was described in the book. Mostly that they were written as a result of taped conversations between Feynman and a friend of his. This makes it pretty unlikely the books say anything that Feynman didn't actually say (since the conversations were taped), and also is pretty transparent in the book. It also seems kind of more likely to be true than an autobiography, since the impressions have filtered through at least one other person.

I would expect that if five years in a row the "variable income" happens to always be around X, people will start to expect it, will make this expectation a part of their personal finances, and if the next year the income is only X/2, there will be riots in the streets.

Doesn't this kind of already happen with the stock market? I can imagine rioting in the case where people loose half of their investments overnight, but I think it'd be different for a cut in dividends since any economic downturn that reduces land values (and thus land taxes) would correspondingly reduce rents and thus people probably wouldn't be left immediately destitute if dividends cut in half or something.

2Viliam
It is similar, but reducing the UBI would lead to immediate loss of money at hand, for everyone, at the same time. So the reaction would be stronger than if today some people lose money at stock market, which they didn't plan to spend this month anyway.

"Indeed," snapped the other boy. His stern face lightened somewhat. "Tell me, what House do you think you might be sorted into? I'm bound for Slytherin House, of course, like my father Lucius before me. And for you, I'd guess House Hufflepuff, or possibly House Elf."

Draco Malfoy mentioned it previously :)

0Adam Kaufman
Oh good catch, I missed that. Thanks!