jimrandomh comments on Open Thread: July 2010, Part 2 - Less Wrong

6 Post author: Alicorn 09 July 2010 06:54AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (770)

You are viewing a single comment's thread.

Comment author: jimrandomh 27 July 2010 05:46:05AM *  1 point [-]

This is my PGP public key. In the future, anything I write which seems especially important will be signed. This is more for signaling purposes than any fear of impersonation -- signing a post is a way to strongly signal its seriousness.

-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.7 (Cygwin)
mQGiBExOb4IRBAClNdK7kU0hDjEnR9KC+ga8Atu6IJ5pS9rKzPUtV9HWaYiuYldv
VDrMIFiBY1R7LKzbEVD2hc5wHdCUoBKNfNVaGXkPDFFguJ2D1LRgy0omHaxM7AB4
woFmm4drftyWaFhO8ruYZ1qSm7aebPymqGZQv/dV8tSzx8guMh4V0ree3wCgzaVX
wQcQucSLnKI3VbiyZQMAQKcEAI9aJRQoY1WFWaGDsAzCKBHtJIEooc+3+/2STL1R
0QVY/W6rBtJhSxiikBs70oVUt3+gzG2zw8HQMA+eF6ailRXyelUn6EUIm+OVPruh
3TiiNl2fVeF8CbmU08tseonPgcQXTKDXdD+/vqe2STF33Pl5h5fUfNISkho1+VFe
WplpA/wPRAHLKxBnRY42jn32s/XqTtTxii52kp0FELCe4X4Ya1tji9D7TEH4AU0A
wg5piyfrgDYTw+MvhI9KAL+NKLa4bgEe8dETZPl10TJt+zvdHqknIb92NjI8Vsb2
/gfEnT7iaJLC4eUcIExgKBaeq/TVsoelkHfN5h2y06mCKzA5CrQkSmFtZXMgQSBC
YWJjb2NrIDxqaW1AamltcmFuZG9taC5vcmc+iGAEExECACAFAkxOb4ICGwMGCwkI
BwMCBBUCCAMEFgIDAQIeAQIXgAAKCRBjbSzQYXDwqpgoAKCRNLiDtqetV8MXJm21
+GaPpkJa6QCeJ0rUccQbdGpwzmb6HDRd4lf5Uf25Ag0ETE5vghAIAIF8dtzaF81g
CywT5v8pxnyb/0cPLtv23vR98VPbmqZxbojrdltr6AOJM6FodlszBZmlCBX2bLP5
drpp9HZ/2g5O9VeWCqPbkAaZFRhMlSY6Zkq77q592+XSk9Bkb1JUWIMsEeoR6f8d
PVH986mgIFzOOZPn3L3H4v3sCnfaMvuSDZxNHh/s+vBYTTc87wrFNzv0c7WZKtum
1nildgrqK4nksMFg5+rnYdAhooSK27WERTd/WH2QNDXTyGN5HgyPKMz9tOVyEsTC
8JvVDTFjMDzfSFkQv58l6/66HgdBaEZkDbNsgL1Vw6RKDaWFTvt+bZmaLpOGDzOf
YtDZc2KkjxsAAwUH/2QV+AG0x0LR83oAESwpe1YSMDzYs1rP7OBAoTyZ8OAz+TqL
iY5v9MJmzu9XI/TXMs7kC1qCwV7tCCPExJeIQKCj9m6jiCDLPECV5bXC+AZ5t0dU
mIoBDHzJee2DOvO4gjzNM7gOMXi0drxCJGN5JRh5k7kByV9lF7yDZFWkJc7gUc9C
fQSdSnwZelxRDYMVPjnkwmNrOq0LPX27PlfVH+0YjAL1x87WTplfERd20eWk9ifA
1SBofuJlZsl1HFbY0zezgOvv6nJDANN9r/y77dbdV2DQJ2rXnTYGcpo9oA8o1/AF
AbGGgUr/0dJMMKrhpdsJZ77Mub3HRZEfEzUlFZaISQQYEQIACQUCTE5vggIbDAAK
CRBjbSzQYXDwquHMAJ43MgAxTE/2fsV+THKFJ1agjsHamACfVeL7pNlDC+fu3GbB
gZ24idwJE1o=
=PiOo
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
Comment author: bogus 27 July 2010 07:18:35AM 1 point [-]

You may want to copy this key block to a user page on the LW wiki, where it can be easily referenced in the future.

Comment author: khafra 27 July 2010 05:45:22PM 1 point [-]

That would also have the advantage of hopefully requiring different credentials to access, so it would be marginally harder to change the recorded public key while signing a forged post with it.

Comment author: bogus 27 July 2010 06:15:34PM 2 points [-]

Not just harder; it would be all but impossible since the wiki keeps a hstory of all changes (unlike LW posts) and jimrandomh is not a wiki sysop.

Comment author: ata 27 July 2010 09:29:37PM 0 points [-]

signing a post is a way to strongly signal its seriousness.

Telling people what you're trying to signal is a way to make them take your signaling less seriously.

Comment author: SilasBarta 01 August 2010 06:02:48AM 2 points [-]

But PGP's security and quality pretty much make up for that loss in signaling seriousness, don't you think?

Comment author: jimrandomh 02 August 2010 03:49:14PM 1 point [-]

It still works as a signal, because (1) signing a comment requires some extra effort, and (2) it is harder to retract a comment that has been signed (since the signature remains valid proof of authorship even if the original comment is edited or deleted). A little bit of real cost and utility goes a long way.

Comment author: Psy-Kosh 01 August 2010 05:48:39AM 0 points [-]

Unless you're signalling that you know about signalling including acknowledging your own signalling. :)