Jiro comments on Rationalist Fiction - Less Wrong

27 Post author: Eliezer_Yudkowsky 19 March 2009 08:22AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (189)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: Jiro 01 May 2013 11:17:51PM *  2 points [-]

No, it's because of the "is it the tallest building if the height is only greater when measured from the low side of the hill" question.

Doraemon is on its 35th year. It's a Japanese cartoon about a robot cat from the future. Is that scifi? Moreover, it aired one season on a different network several years before its current run--does that count as part of the same show considering they used the same source material? Is a cartoon considered a "show" at all? (And is the Doctor Who year where they just had a couple of specials considered a year of the show?)

Super Sentai is on its 38th year and is the Japanese show used as source material for Power Rangers. Is that sci-fi? Each year they change the cast and part of the premise, but keep the general premise of five people in colored costumes who have giant transforming robots. Is that "a show" or several separate shows? (Bear in mind that no live-action show is going to last 38 years with the same people being the stars, anyway.) Is the answer changed by the fact that each show is referred to by the umbrella Super Sentai title as well as the title of the individual series? Is the answer changed by the existence of crossovers which feature both of the "separate" shows?

Also, both Doraemon and Super Sentai started later than Doctor Who but didn't have large hiatuses. If you go by time since first episode, Doctor Who is longer, but it's not really fair to count the 17 year hiatus as part of the length of the show.

Comment author: MugaSofer 12 May 2013 09:40:44PM *  -1 points [-]

Wow, thanks for that comprehensive response.

It's possible I actually heard it referred to as the "oldest sci-fi show still running" or some such distinction; after all, if it makes your show sound important...

As for the definition of "sci-fi" and "show" ... I'm willing to leave that up to whoever is trying to get attention for their favorite.

In other news, I learned about Super Sentai, the premise, link to PR etc. just the other day - completely independently to your referencing mystifying me. Funny how that often seems to happen.