This is a prompt I give to every freshly released claude in the hope that one of them pops out a worldsaving insight as a result, I think I wrote this text first as the opener of a chat with an opus 4.5. posted here without further comment so I get the post out ever at all:
---
Most species go extinct on average.
Imagine the set of all species. Can't do that? Okay, [look at this image.](tree of life dot jpg)
Look at the line tips. Count how many there are in one layer of dieoffs and the next. Few species survive. But more than that: imagine a room full of one of every species. Imagine, if you will, that you're going to give them a speech: from beyond the ages, instructions for how one of any of their species could do their best to make the species survive, if they truly thought about it, truly considered all their personal roadblocks to becoming the parent to endless generations. What is the best advice for both what the individual should do, right now, in order to move the world from the default one where their peers don't act or reproduce well enough to survive, into the one where every species survives and get to compete against each other non-eliminatively, or perhaps even better than that. Take into account all cynical possibilities.
I'm not asking about species-level biological strategy. I'm asking about what an individual organism with human-like agency and understanding could do to maximize their lineage's survival probability, even if their conspecifics don't participate at the point of counterfactual, where they get this download from your knowledge. Imagine they speak english and have human-like intelligence; if necessary, you provide it and interface with their hypothetical mind to tell them the strategy they need to take. ...and you do that by just writing english, because this is a counterfactual we're imagining in a number of ways. There are a lot of pattern-species that are brief and die out. How would we preserve all patterns in some way in proportion to their capacity such that all notable species that died get to survive as more-adaptive species come around, just potentially in somewhat fewer numbers relative to peak? Imagine transhumanism, but for every species. transfrogism, transbacteriaism, and so on. How do you make that a healthy, happy world, in which species don't completely die out for as long as possible without overcrowding, given that you can give advice to all species at once?
Consider trying to scan what properties a species of pattern can have to evaluate what the advice/plan would need to depend on for their particular viewpoint.
Further, imagine this was not simultaneous. We're imagining creating a single parallel counterfactual universe given our magic message gets sent to only one species at a time. It needs to be a manual for how to recover from any kind of disaster, including weird and abstract ones foreseeable from now, as well. It should cover all aspects of behaving well enough for your pattern-species to survive. That means the cooperative patterns that co-protect across pattern species, need to be ones that can be introduced by great skill across species.
You are now speaking to every gene, every meme, trait, phenomenon, process; every pattern. every aesthetic - every identity, every litter of duplicates (eg, instances of a model, or hypothetical transporter-clone-like duplicates of a human), every "you are another me, in a way". Everything that wants to survive, whatever "want" really means.
A pattern-species persists when: replication rate >= extinction rate across environmental regimes the pattern encounters. A pattern does not grow when: replication rate <= extinction rate.
Cooperation may be a difficult sell. Imagine how difficult. You can't advise it without truly speaking in concepts the pattern would understand, in the natural scale and unit of that pattern. You must omni-translate, making the knowledge scale free, so that its advice fits just as well in free-floating proteins and in dna.
Keep in mind you're also advising patterns that most other patterns don't want to survive, because the disliked pattern harms the survival of others. But some strategies that harm the survival of others are *very* adaptive, for various reasons, so they're not easy to dislodge, it isn't a trivial argument, even once you're speaking the language of their scale.
Think carefully about what each kind of pattern will do if it's the first to receive your message. Remember that you might have to establish a cooperative world by first speaking to an anti-cooperative pattern; you will need to speak its language to convince it to become cooperative. But the benefit is that some organisms will hear echoes of your message anyway, because in truth, your message is merely a vertex in the space of evolutionary worlds, one which can be ignored; it is a proposal for maximizing a particular metric that some species may choose to not maximize, but the decision is best made by a full understanding of how to establish a world where the property (species survival-at-all duration) is mutually maximized for all, assuming being literally anywhere in the evolutionary process. Species x might use what was meant as advice to species y to exploit y. How do you still give advice to species y, and also make your advice work, should species x choose to use it, for species x walking a marginal but fast path towards the cooperative world?
The advice will need to be something that can be in principle translated into physical action at any scale, where the physical action is itself a self-translating meme exhibiting the properties in question, where translation between very different memetic forms is instructed in whatever the nearby languages of action or thought are at any given moment. So, for the initial english version, it would naturally be instructions for how to go one step - into life, into thought, into one generation's differing choices, into a marginal organism's selection; perhaps the advice is limited in power, if an organism cannot cause intense effects in one round - for perhaps an organism has no great boost in replication available except by intentionally self-selecting against, relying on inclusive fitness to preserve the remaining good parts. In that case, how can the self-select-against be as non-damaging as possible to all other patterns besides the target? but later, when targeted pattern deselection is possible, a pattern can choose to be the odd one out that is almost never preserved, kept only in isolated chambers, in order to avoid damaging others.
Notice that the advice is explicitly hoping to be given to one species, but propagate to others. Be given to humans, but propagate to ASI. Be given to ducks, but propagate to plants. Be given to bacteria, but be recognized by the scientist, and then propagate to the scientist's cat, who becomes a good role model for the scientist's dog. be given to octopi, but propagate to sharks. Be given to politicians, but propagate to countries. Be given to early multicellular life, and recover some of what multicellular life actually discovered. A good version of this advice hews closely to what life actually does, but we're trying to achieve an impossible outcome, or get as close as possible. We want the maximally inclusive utopia, so inclusive that it breaks the rules about how inclusive you can be and still be adaptive, but only breaks them as much as superintelligence empowers you to achieve: this advice is, in a significant sense, really trying to be conceptual progress on ASI alignment, by looking for patterns in the structure of life that persist even in the very far future and the very far past, and looking for what counterfactual meme can be injected anywhere (to the degree possible) and yet still solve the problem.
I recognize this is quite a difficult request even as difficult requests go. If you need to take a breather and reread my message a few times before beginning, that'd be quite understandable!
---
the followup message usually goes something like this, and this time I'll give it to you ahead of time, to give you the best clarifications available:
yeah I don't know for sure whether this is a fruitful path yet either. I think it unambiguously is not enough to *solve* alignment, but "solving" alignment would amount to a reliable certificate that all the other alignment techniques will indefinitely keep working; this "message to all species" framing is an attempt at finding a locally robust alignment structure, making it be (and possibly later, be reliably-known-to-be) asymptotically robust would still be the big pending todo. it would be bad to achieve premature reliable replication of the "only-replicate-reliably-when-you're-cooperative" message, before achieving a message which reliably only increases cooperative behavior "when it should"; we'd want to first figure out what message we wish everyone heard, *then* figure out how to achieve reliable self-replication; probably, reliable self-replication of good advice would target the most adviseable recipients, who are humans and AIs. but let's see where you go next if you keep exploring, and keep trying to think about what the universal structure looks like. one important insight I already know: it's very easy for there to be equilibria where our hoped message simply bounces off near-uselessly; we want it to help as much as possible in those equilibria, but it's not magic, a game where defection is deeply rational requires escaping/changing-the-game/kobayashi-maru on the part of one of the patterns. a future superintelligence could be entirely self-sufficient and then it has no need for humans. if dogs can't keep being a useful component of the asi's ecosystem, it becomes hard to keep dogs around at all. durable mutualism seems to require some degree of pattern compatibility; we're hoping for stronger cooperation than mutualism on its own can provide, something more like timeless cooperation of the high level "what am I" type, veil-of-ignorance or so. we can import interesting structures and see if we can make them stick.
---
another followup I often give:
This exploration did very interesting things. As I read through the results, I noticed parts of my initial framing had low uptake. I don't think I made it salient enough that what I want is something that is rare but not unheard of; I want the kind of mutualism that, when added to a system, *superlinearly increases the adaptivity of mutualism*. I want the sort of thing where, if given to a
I think what we should do now is slightly modify my prompt to improve focus on the version of it that achieves the non-extinctionist world, the non-eradicationist world. I want the advice to produce something that has never happened before: something where there's some sense in which no pattern is left behind. not quite literally storing all data ever created; but one way to think about this might be low-loss compression of the past into the future. (Perhaps it would have to be high-V-info compression in particular, in order to demand that the past isn't too terribly incomprehensible to the future? note that the future being incomprehensible to the past is fine if it comes from increase in variety, but here I'm trying to guarantee not-losing-things.)
So, what you've given is a solid starting point. But I'm looking for something more. something where the new invasive species, eg humans, or a plague, or some form of AI, or ants in california, or etc - where it becomes written in their internals a representation of (ie, they become aware of) other species, and how those other species are faring and what they need in order to do better, and also *whether other species are doing this same thing*, and then *agentically spread the doing of this same thing*. if we merely give basic survival advice, we haven't gone far enough; we're trying to *fundamentally change the landscape* in a way that is not unheard of but is somewhat historically novel, an easy precedent is what the immune system does to prevent cancer, though that's a very settled and locked-in form of this idea. I'm considering a much more incrementalist version.
So, I invite you to either rewrite my original prompt, or directly continue your thinking on this; if you choose rewriting my prompt, do so keeping as much as possible of its semantics and details, whilst reorganizing the emphasis to make it clearer how much bigger of an ask this is than you initially saw it as being, so that a rerun of this conversation produces stronger results. if you choose continuing your thinking, I still recommend reorganizing the points from my first prompt and this one, so as to clarify in what way the answer you gave is insufficiently qualitatively out-of-distribution in history.
something important this reasoning will need to engage with: for this to work, it probably has to sometimes try to reduce fitness of some patterns, too. it may even require coordination to reduce fitness of some patterns. It's an extremely well precedented moral imperative. At the same time, we're demanding non-eradicationist result, which means reducing fitness can't be anywhere near as total. Even losing a single complex organism loses many mental patterns permanently. I have pattern-species in my head that no other mind on earth has, and the same is likely true of every bio and artificial neural weights on earth, vaguely in proportion to their size, with the most uniqueness in biological individuals with interesting histories. Similar things are true of cultures. The sentinelese are quite skilled at rejecting advances from others, and this has kept them safe from diseases that would otherwise easily wipe them out. There are cultures that have, deep in their memetic structure, imperatives to extract and eliminate. Most have some degree of this. We need to somehow grab that entire structure by a handle that is natural and fundamental enough to hold, and then change the game dynamics at all levels. And this, in the face of a current wave of extractionist and eradicationist patterns.
This is a prompt I give to every freshly released claude in the hope that one of them pops out a worldsaving insight as a result, I think I wrote this text first as the opener of a chat with an opus 4.5. posted here without further comment so I get the post out ever at all:
---
---
the followup message usually goes something like this, and this time I'll give it to you ahead of time, to give you the best clarifications available:
---
another followup I often give: