1530

LESSWRONG
LW

1529
ParentingPractical
Personal Blog

29

Offering Completion

by jefftk
7th Jun 2024
jefftk
1 min read
6

29

29

Offering Completion
10Dave Orr
3athom
7bhauth
3mikbp
3jefftk
1mikbp
New Comment
6 comments, sorted by
top scoring
Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 11:21 AM
[-]Dave Orr1y102

Children are evidently next word completers.

Reply1
[-]athom1y35

Less so once they've done enough RLHF

Reply
[-]bhauth1y76

Works with MBAs too.

Reply1
[-]mikbp1y30

In what toddler age span has this worked for your children?

Reply
[-]jefftk1y30

I didn't write it down, so don't trust this much, but something like 2-3.5?

Reply
[-]mikbp1y10

Thanks!

Reply
Moderation Log
More from jefftk
View more
Curated and popular this week
6Comments
ParentingPractical
Personal Blog

One verbal approach I often find useful with little kids is to offer them the opportunity to complete a phrase. Compare:

Parent: It's time to brush teeth!

Toddler: I no want brush teef!

vs:

Parent: It's time to brush...

Toddler: Teef!

Similarly, "the dirty tissue goes in the...", "when we get home it will be time to put pee in the...", "it's time to eat...", etc. My experience is that, at the right age, kids just really love getting to complete things, and this somehow spills over into their attitude towards the thing they're completing. Or having it come from their mouth somehow manufactures buy-in, or skips the normal opportunity for them to (as is also common at this age) say no?

One nice safeguard this has is that while it's mildly manipulative, once they lose their joy at completing things it stops working. So it doesn't have the risk that you'll keep using it at an age where (in my opinion) manipulating kids starts to be a problem.

Comment via: facebook, mastodon