You keep on describing neutrinos as "undetectable". How do you interpret this catalogue of neutrino detectors? BTW, the neutrino idea took shape in 1930-1934, long before the Standard Model was formulated, to explain beta decay.
Neutrinos are inferred from their decay products. These products can have other explanations, especially in high-energy environments wherein there are many interactors.
The vibe I'm getting here is Reddit 2.0. Tell me that's not the case.
I don't mind the downvotes, but could you at least offer some feedback as to why you gave it?
I hardly use Reddit, so I don't know what is intended by the comparison with Reddit 2.0.
You are coming across to me as either a crank or a crackpot, and the "Manic" handle isn't helping. I see no mathematics in what you have posted, and without mathematics, there is no physics. The theory, so far as it is saying definite things, gives no reasons for these particular things. Your insistence that neutrinos have not been detected is supported only by saying there may be other explanations for all the supposed detections, without giving any. This argument could be applied equally well to most of the known subatomic particles, including the gluons that you reply on.
Could you provide an example of prediction the Γ Framework makes which highlights the divergence between it and the Standard Model? Especially in cases the Standard Model falls short of describing reality well enough?
Thank you for the question.
One prediction the Γ Framework makes is in the area of muon decay. In the Standard Model, a muon decays into an electron, a muon neutrino, and an electron neutrino. This relies on the existence of undetectable neutrinos to account for the missing energy. The Γ Framework, by contrast, eliminates the need for neutrinos altogether.
In the Γ Framework, a muon (43Γ) decays directly into two electrons (2 x 20Γ) and three 1Γ gluons, which then decay into six gamma-ray photons. The entire energy balance (105 MeV) is accounted for via photon-photon interactions. This divergence highlights a fundamental shift: whereas the Standard Model introduces undetectable particles to conserve energy, the Γ Framework explains particle decay entirely through photon-based interactions.
This prediction could be tested by revisiting high-precision experiments on muon decay, looking for potential discrepancies in missing energy or gamma-ray emissions ("halo data") where the Standard Model currently predicts neutrinos.
Another area of divergence is the interpretation of proton-proton fusion. In the Standard Model, proton fusion releases energy partly through neutrinos. The Γ Framework, however, posits that this energy is carried entirely by photon-photon interactions and the emission of gamma rays, offering a cleaner explanation without the need for neutrinos.
In both cases, the Standard Model falls short in providing a direct observable explanation for neutrino-based processes, while the Γ Framework predicts energy outcomes that could be more empirically testable with future advancements.
Your model of muon decay doesn't conserve charge -- you start with -1e , then have -2e and finally have zero. Also, the second electron is never observed.
You made a couple of interesting points.
First, the Γ Framework doesn't use charge. I know that so radical, right!?! Instead, it uses the oscillatory resonances of coupled photons (1Γ gluons) to form, stabilize and polarize particles.
In addition, like lepton numbers, charge is a construct - a useful tool but not necessarily the endgame in physics.
Also, keep in mind the volumes of interactors. Until there's a way to actually count both muons and electrons, then all we can honestly say is x muons decay into y electrons (and, possibly, unconfined gluons that disintegrate into photons). We don't know the actual ratio because, currently, there's no way to know.
Besides, there's another model that addresses the dynamics from a level below the SM that suggests it's not the ground floor. :)
Models evolve. Like any fleeting zeitgeist, consensuses change.
A Photon-Based Unification of Fundamental Forces
Introduction: A New Model for Unifying Forces Through Photon Interactions
In modern physics, the Standard Model has successfully described the fundamental particles and forces of nature. However, there are gaps and complexities—such as the reliance on undetectable particles like neutrinos and the separation of fundamental forces—that suggest the need for alternative models. The Γ Framework presents a photon-based approach that unifies all fundamental forces (electromagnetic, weak, strong, and gravitational) through photon-photon interactions.
This model proposes that all particle interactions, including the formation of quarks and gluons, stem from a single foundational process: the coupling of photons mediated by 1Γ gluons. By eliminating unnecessary particles and focusing solely on photon interactions, the Γ Framework offers a simplified, dynamic, and unified theory of energy and forces.
The LessWrong community values clear, evidence-based reasoning, and this post seeks to present the Γ Framework in those terms. While this model diverges from the Standard Model, it remains grounded in the principles of rationality, probabilistic thinking, and a genuine curiosity about where it might be wrong or where it can be improved.
Core Concepts: The Energy Progression Series
At the heart of the Γ Framework is the idea that energy evolves through a progression series, leading from basic mass-energy equivalence to a unified energy state where all forces and particles arise from photon interactions.
This is Einstein’s famous equation, which serves as the starting point for understanding energy as the equivalence of mass and energy. It forms the base of the progression series, where energy is seen as mass-based.
Here, energy is expressed through photon interactions, where photon energy E=ℏω (E=E_γ) is quantized based on the photon's frequency. This stage moves beyond mass-based energy to energy emerging from the behavior of photons, introducing quantization.
At this level, photon-photon interactions dominate. The coupling of photons, mediated by 1Γ gluons, represents energy exchanges that give rise to forces. This is where the framework begins to describe energy exchanges at a fundamental level, explaining how higher-order processes such as electromagnetic, weak, and strong forces originate.
As photon-photon interactions merge, they form a unified energy framework. Distinct forces like electromagnetism, weak, and strong forces become part of a single energy system, described by photon-photon interactions. The 1Γ gluon acts as the mediator for these couplings.
The final stage of the progression is the unified Γ parameter, which encapsulates the total energy from photon-photon interactions. At this point, all forces and particles are understood as manifestations of photon interactions. This collapse into a single governing variable offers a much simpler and unified view of energy.
Summary of Energy Progression:
E = mc² → E = E_γ (E=ℏω) → E = E_γγ → E = E_Γ → E = Γ
Gamma Factors and Particles by Gamma Factors
In the Γ Framework, each particle is assigned a Gamma factor (Γ), representing its energy state and interactions with photons. Below are some examples:
This system simplifies the classification of particles by focusing on their energy states rather than on the need for complex intermediary particles. Note: the most stable particles resemble Platonic solid-like shapes.
Muon Decay Without Neutrinos
In contrast to the Standard Model, where neutrinos are introduced to conserve energy in muon decay, the Γ Framework offers a simplified process:
This process preserves energy conservation without the additional complexity introduced by neutrinos, presenting a more streamlined decay pathway.
In this approach, lepton numbers are not treated as inviolable, and particle interactions are explained through energy redistribution rather than adhering to the traditional lepton number conservation laws of the Standard Model.
Proton-Proton Fusion Explained Through Photon Interactions
The Γ Framework provides a photon-based explanation for proton-proton fusion:
This explains the energy release during fusion without requiring neutrinos, presenting a cleaner model of nuclear fusion that relies entirely on photon interactions.
The Dark Domain
In the Γ Framework, photons are removed from the Standard Model and placed into a regime called the Dark Domain. This domain represents a foundational state of energy where photon-photon interactions generate the particles and forces we observe in the Standard Model.
Dynamic Energy Redistribution and Photon Interactions
One of the key innovations of the Γ Framework is its emphasis on dynamic energy redistribution through photon-photon interactions:
Conclusion: The Journey from Photons to Forces
The Γ Framework provides a photon-centric view of the universe, simplifying complex forces and particle interactions by focusing on photon-photon couplings. By eliminating the need for undetectable particles and offering a unified energy progression series, the model presents a fresh approach to understanding the universe.
For the LessWrong audience, this model is relevant because it challenges existing assumptions in a rational, evidence-based way. It encourages exploration of alternative frameworks that could eventually complement or even replace aspects of the Standard Model.
While this framework is still in its theoretical stages, it offers a promising avenue for rethinking how energy, forces, and particles are interconnected at the most fundamental level.