This proposition is already barely tenable within the confines of our Milky Way, which contains 100 to 400 billion stars. But the probability of us being the only spacefaring species in the Virgo Supercluster, with up to 200 trillion stars in it, is so vanishingly low that at this point we would be better served by considering more exotic (e.g. simulation theory, quantum immortality) or even theological explanations (e.g. "[a] God exists and made Creation for us and us alone").
The conditions necessary for being able to support life in theory certainly exist in many, many places in the universe. But favorable conditions aren't enough. Life must actually arise from non-life.
We have no complete theory of abiogenesis and therefore no idea how likely it is to occur on any given planet. Your argument that we could not be the only spacefaring species in the Virgo Supercluster seems to be based solely on incredulity that life could be sufficiently unlikely to make this probable.
But why not? The probability of life spontaneously forming is related as inverse exponential to the complexity of the chemical reactions required to spontaneously generate that life. The simplest living organism we know of has a HEAVILY compressed DNA sequence of about 50,000 base pairs, all of which are most likely load-bearing. Back of the envelope, this means the spontaneous generation of this organism is less likely than 1 in 4^50,000, or about 1 in 1e30000, to say nothing of the machinery required for actually transcribing the DNA and synthesizing proteins. A number like 200 trillion vanishes into nothing before odds like these. This is so unlikely, that it's basically certain not to happen in any particular Hubble Volume, let alone the virgo supercluster.
Now, obviously the first life-forms ever would be simpler than this. But it depends very much on exactly how much simpler. You see just how quickly the odds can stack up? Even if the first, simple life forms required a reaction only 1% as complicated as the hypothetical spontaneous generation I've mentioned, it would still be extremely unlikely that there is another event like it within the observable universe.
Now, again, we don't know how likely abiogenesis is! It could be that there's a likely enough pathway that there are aliens all over the place. But it could also be very, very unlikely. AFAIK we don't yet know of anything saying it has to be likely enough that we would expect aliens within the Virgo Supercluster or even the entire observable universe.
Abiogenesis being a major hurdle seems, to say the least, much less exotic of an idea than, say, simulation gods or theological gods or quantum immortality
Or any of the other several steps between bare minimum life and rockets. If we are judging solely by the history of life on Earth - and we don't have much more else to go on - then it would seem that human level intelligence is rare for complex life forms, and complex life forms are rare among replicators in general. This is not strong evidence, but it is not no evidence either, and the track record of wild guesses about domains we don't have robust theory for is not exactly great.
Why not? It's a pretty big hurdle given that we've never yet been able to observe or induce it. In all other areas of biology, the assumption is that a living organism must arise from another, similar, living organism. Abiogenesis would be a massive exception to that rule. The only reason we even think it's possible at all is because it must be, by observation, since life did arise. We have little idea how, though, and all specific proposals so far are vanishingly unlikely.
Now, perhaps there's a way which isn't so unlikely we just haven't found yet, or perhaps all the specific pathways are really unlikely, but together become likely enough.
What's the argument for not considering it a major hurdle though?
Similar claims have been advanced in defence of panspermia or creationism. The consensus among evolutionary biologists is that such claims misrepresent abiogenesis as being fundamentally driven by random probability when in reality it was driven by natural selection over a multitude of intermediate steps, not massive jumps between one level of complexity and the next.
Im aware creationists use this argument. I think they could be right about the extremely low probability, though they definitely exaggerate it sometimes. The main flaw in their argument is the part at the end, where they say "and that's why god/aliens must have done it instead", as though that were a simpler and more likely explanation instead of just another much larger thing needing further explanation.
The fundamental problem is that, in order for natural selection to start at all, you need descent with variation, and it isn't yet clear just how complicated exactly the minimum, bare-bones setup is for successful descent with variation.
There may be multiple steps, but im concerned mainly with just how unlikely the very first step is. The one which kickstarts natural selection, when none was occurring previously.
This isn't my field though, so there may well be results I'm unaware of.
the probability of us being the only spacefaring species in the Virgo Supercluster, with up to 200 trillion stars in it, is so vanishingly low
Why? We don't even know any other biospheres...
Our sample size is tiny. We've only characterised the atmospheres of nine terrestrial exoplanets to a high degree of confidence, all of them since 2024.
But plugging realistic figures into the rare Earth equation yields between 0.1 and 100 planets with complex life per galaxy the size of the Milky Way. Extrapolating that to the Virgo Supercluster yields between 100 and 100,000.
Even if we take the most pessimistic end of that range and say complex life only has a 5% probability of eventually progressing to something like our current level of tech, if cosmophagous AI were really a thing, we should still expect to have been devoured by one already.
plugging realistic figures into the rare Earth equation yields between 0.1 and 100 planets with complex life per galaxy the size of the Milky Way
What rules out P(complex life | habitable planet) being extremely low?
if cosmophagous AI were really a thing, we should still expect to have been devoured by one already.
Had we been, we would not be around to observe it.
No-one playing Russian roulette ever observes a loaded chamber.
We are not randomly selected from all civilisations that have appeared by now, including posthumous ones.
Suppose that that cosmophagous AI is the inevitable fate of every civilisation (unless something else gets them first, like their sun going nova), and that it travels at the speed of light or as near as makes no difference, i.e. no civilisation sees one coming. Who would then be in a position to observe an empty universe, as we appear to? Everyone, until they either trigger one themselves or are obliterated by another. That is, sufficiently fast cosmophagous AI looks to any observer exactly like the universe we see.
Ramping up the speed of expansion (to allow for cosmophagous AI that can sneak on us undetected), would only make our current existence more unlikely, as it expands the radius inside which a cosmophagous AI could have been created and still had time to find us and consume us.
Going from 0.1 c to 0.99 c would increase this radius to ~5.5 billion light-years. To give you a sense of just how big that is, the Pisces–Cetus Supercluster Complex, the largest known structure that Earth is part of, is "only" 1.24 billion light-years across.
That actually seems close to in range. It would take one conceptual error in that Rare Earth estimate to get us there.
Nonetheless, that doesn't seem like the likeliest explanation.
I find this twist on the Fermi Paradox truly baffling. I hadn't realized the neighbors were so close in relation to the time available for evolution to work.
When you say the oldest metal-rich stars are that old, what fraction of is that old?
When you say the oldest metal-rich stars are that old, what fraction of is that old?
It depends on your sample population. Near the sun, pop I age distributions are roughly uniform on [0, 10] gyr, but the sun is a typical member of a youngish region. The further out you go, the worse our data is, but so far as we know, cosmically, most stars are close to solar metallicity, and the median star age is maybe 9 gyr, ish.
Well we should factor that in obviously. I just didn't know if most suns with adequate materials are as young or much younger than ours. I see that my understanding was biased by bad assumptions about neighborhoods and travel times; probably most work on the Fermi problem limited itself to our galaxy, assuming that biologicals might not bother with intergalactic travel. Maximizing ASI would.
Our star being that much younger than average makes this paradox all the more troubling. What the hell? This now strikes me as possibly highly relevant for the AI problem.
One could counter with an extreme version of the rare Earth hypothesis, claiming that intelligent life is so mind-bogglingly rare in the Universe that, statistically, we shouldn't expect to have met cosmophagous AI (or other forms of grabby aliens) yet.
This proposition is already barely tenable within the confines of our Milky Way, which contains 100 to 400 billion stars. But the probability of us being the only spacefaring species in the Virgo Supercluster, with up to 200 trillion stars in it, is so vanishingly low that at this point we would be better served by considering more exotic (e.g. simulation theory, quantum immortality) or even theological explanations (e.g. "[a] God exists and made Creation for us and us alone").
What assumptions did you make to conclude the likelihood is low? It seems to me that we don't have a good handle on abiogenesis or the transition to cellular life or the transition to multicellular life, and that any of these things could have been very unlikely. Suppose the odds of a random star being host to multicellular life is 1 in 10^30. The visible universe has around 10^24 stars, so a random portion of the universe of that size wouldn't be expected to have any multicellular life. And any life that evolves is very likely to have a large gap between itself and the nearest other star that birthed multicellular life. I don't point this out to argue that 1 in 10^30 is the correct number, rather to note that what we're seeing is what you'd expect if something about life is very unlikely.
Making the argument that it's unlikely for us to be the only spacefaring species in the Virgo Supercluster seems to suppose some reasonably high probability that a star births multicellular organisms, but we don't know what that probability would be, it could be extremely low, it could require some insane sequence of events where two asteroids from different areas with different animo acids on them land close to each other on a planet with lightning storms or something. The point is that if any part of getting from the initial conditions of the universe to building an cosmophagous AI is really really unlikely, then it makes sense you wouldn't see a high density of them.
Your logic would also apply to anything else that'd be visible to us, not just cosmophagous AI. Grabby aliens more generally, Dyson spheres, powerful radio transmissions, exploration probes, etc. Given what we know about humans' ability to make things and propensity to shout into space, it doesn't seem likely to me that it is impossible to create things that are visible to other planets, nor that being smart enough to do so automatically instills sufficient foreboding about what might be out there to not do so. The simplest explanation seems to me to be that it was quite unlikely for a given planet to get this far, rather than inferring that there must be even harder blockers ahead that'd stop us being visible. It seems like getting from a bunch of hydrogen to sentient beings is a journey that's far harder than getting from sentient beings to being visible to sentient beings on other planets. The first bit is probably the part that the rest of the planets got stuck on, not the final leg.
But the probability of us being the only spacefaring species in the Virgo Supercluster, with up to 200 trillion stars in it, is so vanishingly low that at this point we would be better served by considering more exotic (e.g. simulation theory, quantum immortality) or even theological explanations (e.g. "[a] God exists and made Creation for us and us alone").
Multiverse and theological explanations should of course be given some weight, but fairly low depending on what exactly they're trying to explain and how they do compared to other explanations. What's your argument that the probability of no other life is vanishingly low that it ends up lower than other explanations?
(I exclude simulation theory as it seems borderline incoherent.)
Also, multiverse theory can serve as a partial explanation of why we exist here at all despite a very low probability of life emerging. So rather than competing with the "no other life" theory, it's complementary to it.
My argument is that even if you plug the most pessimistic (but still realistic) figures into the rare Earth equation, you still get ~100 planets with complex life existing in the Virgo Supercluster at present (more, of course, if you expand the range to span the last 10 billion years). Using middle-of-the road figures yields as many as ~50,000.
To get figures pessimistic enough to make Earth the only planet with complex life in the whole supercluster, we would have to resort to arguments that fly in the face of the scientific consensus, such as Hoyle's fallacy.
On the other hand, the arguments for us being alone in the Universe are themselves reliant on extremely low probabilities. For example, in his counterargument to my post, Andrew Sauer suggested that the odds of the first step of abiogenesis could be as low as 1 in 4^500. Let's assume, for the sake of the argument, that Andrew is right: would you say the odds of us currently existing by sheer luck are higher than the odds of this Universe being a simulation or created by God? I wouldn't. I believe the probability of simulation, quantum immortality and/or God being true is many orders of magnitude than 1 in 4^500.
Quantum is overly specific as there are many other forms of multiverses that may be likelier.
What do you make of https://arxiv.org/abs/1806.02404 which argues that plausible parameters result in a high chance of being alone?
would you say the odds of us currently existing by sheer luck are higher than the odds of this Universe being a simulation or created by God?
This is slightly off. You need to think through anthropics and have some kind of background theory to start comparing odds. For instance, even without a traditional multiverse, if you have a sufficiently large world then the probability of life somewhere in that world can be high. But also, you need to use something like Solomonoff induction to formalize the kind of reasoning you're trying to use here. And then the question becomes "what is simpler: a computation that simulates our universe, then locates us within it to specify our experiences? Or a computation that simulates our universe and also has a higher universe running that simulation?"
The latter is going to be more complex under any reasonable specification. You don't actually gain any simplicity by postulating a simulator.
Sandberg, Drexler and Ord are basically engaging in Hoyle's fallacy, aren't they? They reduce abiogenesis to a matter of blind chance, without even considering (or even mentioning!) natural selection in their paper.
Their "plausible parameters" are not so plausible anymore when you take into account the role of natural selection on even the earliest molecules on the road to life.
They're taking parameter estimates from elsewhere in the literature.
Not clear why Hoyle's thing is considered a fallacy - the Wikipedia page you linked to commits a fallacy of authority in the opening paragraph by saying Hoyle was an atheist, it doesn't seem like a good source for understanding this.
They mention evolution on page 8 and acknowledge large uncertainty as to the parameters here. Why do you believe there's less uncertainty? There's further discussion of natural selection on page 4 of Supplement I
Agreed that ecophagous or heliophagous entities are much more of an immediate concern, whether it's "just" a stage toward cosmophageous (first I'd heard the term - I like it, though Hanson's "grabby" is more evocative), or a goal in itself or a means to other, more esoteric goals.
That said, the limits of observation and inference at this distance in time/space make my uncertainty about such probability calculations significantly larger than the (small) probabilities being calculated. I wouldn't make any big decisions based on my modeling of long-distance (in time and/or space) behaviors of entities that may or may not exist.
considering more exotic (e.g. simulation theory, quantum immortality) or even theological explanations (e.g. "[a] God exists and made Creation for us and us alone").
I think simulation theory isn’t all that exotic as an explanation for why we don’t see highly advanced alien civilizations around us.
We find ourselves in a rather unique position from the perspective of the simulation hypothesis:
1. We seem to be just one step away from the emergence of ASI and the technological singularity.
2. We are on a planet where our civilization’s level of intelligence falls within a very narrow range: we are capable of taking adequate measures before ASI emerges, but whether we actually will is far from obvious. (My assumption is that a difference of literally just + or - one SD would make the question of alignment trivial, one way or the other.)
3. We live in an expanding universe with a strict speed-of-light limit (which is rather convenient for a simulation), where we receive no signals from other highly advanced civilizations that could help us solve the problem.
Apparently, all three of these conditions are necessary for the simulation hypothesis to be relevant. If even one of them were absent, it should reduce the probability that we’re living in a simulation. But whichever way you look at it, we have all three.
Cosmophagous AI (my name for AI that races desperately at near-light speeds to grab that last galaxy, that last star, that last planet before it forever recedes over the cosmological horizon) is sometimes invoked as a counterargument to the idea that even an ASI that is mostly indifferent to our fate would keep us around if the cost of doing so were sufficiently low.
For example, Ryan Greenblatt makes the following point in Notes on fatalities from AI takeover:
Writing in the comment section, Tanner Cook counters:
In this post, I argue that our observational evidence and, indeed, our very existence is a strong argument against the existence of cosmophagous AI.
Our bubble in space
The oldest metal-rich stars (population I), which are capable of supporting star systems comparable to our own, are estimated to have appeared roughly 10 billion years ago. Even if we assume the earliest spacefaring civilisations took about the same time to evolve as human civilisation has on Earth (a conservative estimate), i.e. 4.5 billion years from the formation of their planets, that still gives these civilisations a 5.5-billion-year headstart on us.
At a rather modest velocity of 0.1 c (I say "modest" because many proponents of the idea expect cosmophagous AI to travel at near-light speed in its frantic race to the last atom in the Universe), this means the earliest possible cosmophagous AIs would have been able to devour everything within a radius of 550 million light years.
For perspective, the Virgo Supercluster, the 47,000-galaxy supercluster we are part of, is "only" 147 million light-years across. Even if only a single cosmophagous AI had appeared in this structure, and even if we were lucky enough that it had evolved at exactly the opposite edge of the supercluster, it would have had enough time to catch us and consume us several times over.
And yet, here we are. Not only do our observations see no evidence of distant stars blinking out of the sky as something harvests them for energy (which could be handwaved away by "any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic"), but the fact that we ourselves are still here constitutes prima facie evidence that no cosmophagous AI evolved inside the Virgo Supercluster within the first 8.5 billion years after the first population I stars.
Right now, the atoms in your body are reading these words, processing the information they encode, and using your mouse to scroll down the page. They have not been repurposed into pure computronium or turned into Dyson sphere construction materials!
So, what gives?
There are multiple potential explanations for this (non-exhaustive list, in no particular order):
The why is less important than the what, though: the point is cosmophagous AI is not a thing in the Virgo Supercluster, and any ASI that we build is overwhelmingly likely to come to the same conclusion as any other ASIs developed inside the supercluster within the last 10 billion years: chasing the cosmological horizon is not feasible, desirable and/or necessary to accomplish its goals.
Such an ASI would not operate on an ultra-tight time schedule in which every month of delay costs it millions upon millions of star systems: the Virgo Supercluster will still be accessible in tens of billions of years and can be taken at a leisurely pace, while the Local Group, containing more than a trillion stars, will basically remain accessible forever. If it has even a tiny sliver of care for humans, as Greenblatt suggests, then it could easily afford to delay its expansion by a month, a year or a decade without sacrificing anything meaningful.
A possible counterargument
One could counter with an extreme version of the rare Earth hypothesis, claiming that intelligent life is so mind-bogglingly rare in the Universe that, statistically, we shouldn't expect to have met cosmophagous AI (or other forms of grabby aliens) yet.
This proposition is already barely tenable within the confines of our Milky Way, which contains 100 to 400 billion stars. But the probability of us being the only spacefaring species in the Virgo Supercluster, with up to 200 trillion stars in it, is so vanishingly low that at this point we would be better served by considering more exotic (e.g. simulation theory, quantum immortality) or even theological explanations (e.g. "[a] God exists and made Creation for us and us alone").
Ending on a word of caution
None of this is meant to play down fears of misaligned ASI. To be clear, misaligned ASI could mean a very bad time even if it didn't specifically take the shape of a cosmophagous AI! But I do think it's worthwhile to establish which misalignment scenarios make up a large slice of the probability space, and which ones don't, so we can direct our energy and attention to the former.