I was sitting in a tiny rental lodge, feeling resistance. It was about dinner time — I knew I should go make some food. I just wanted to sleep, sink into a bed and stay passive. It felt similar to when I’m recently awake, lying in bed, and procrastinating getting up.
On the one hand, making food would shift me into a new state of being, getting going and maybe feeling happier. For part of me, this promise didn’t feel real — not in the way the bed did. I realized I was stuck in a tie between Pragmatic-Analysis and Akrasia.1
I shifted out of this impasse by going into Beast-Mode. Practically, I acted out the first hedonistic impulse to appear — grabbing a date and eating it. Shifting my headspace into Beast-Mode helped ease the short-term resistance — the Beast-Mode shift made the possibility of future state-shifting more real. If I could go into temporary Beast-Mode, then surely I can enter a happy salad-making headspace.
My Akrasia headspace is quite stupid, lacking the theory of mind required to understand that my experience and headspace can shift to enjoy many things that temporarily feel “too much” — such as early-morning cold showers. Other headspaces of mine — including Beast-Mode & Pragmatic-Analysis — are much more mature, and able to account for the preferences & goals I hold in other headspaces.
When I’m in these mature states, I can control my reactions and mindset to a large degree — making mental moves to shift how I relate to things. When I’m in Akrasia, I feel resistance that makes everyday things hard to do — washing dishes becomes a slog through a nasty marsh. When I’m in Beast-Mode or Pragmatic-Analysis, washing dishes can be great fun — accompanied by singing, taking my time to make things sparkle, and enjoying the repetition.
Unfortunately, I easily forget that I can shift mindsets around. I “meld” with the negative thought patterns, forgetting other ways of being. When I’m anxious, I resist taking steps to improve the situation, fearful that I’ll do something to provoke even stronger anxiety. When I’m in Akrasia, I’m unable to imagine what flow is like — thinking that the grass is equally brown on the other side, and further away.
Historically, I’ve used Pragmatic-Analysis to deal with most challenges — with great success. However, it’s less efficient when dealing with Akrasia and Anxiety. The analysis easily turn non-productive, serving to affirm dysfunctional headspaces rather than finding a path forward.
Pragmatic-Analysis tends to frame solutions in plans, such as “I’ll step out of bed, go take a shower, then do some breathwork […]”. At this point, Akrasia starts resisting, either shutting down the thoughts or turning the planning into a daydreaming-ideation state. Shifting into Beast-Mode is a better plan — doing something immediately pleasant that is also invigorating/agency-inducing.
The resistance likely comes from the accumulated cost of taking many actions, whereas living in the moment is easy. To give an example: Taking a single step is basically always easy, whereas walking 10 kilometers is not, but walking 10 kilometers is just many, many single steps.
Being able to shift ones headspace or "mode" is a valuable skill, and I can do it to some extent, but there's also sometimes something which gets in the way, and I think it's likely that the mind, in order to protect itself, limits our control over it. By manipulating your belief system, you can lessen your inhibitions, by lowering the perceived threat of less control.
As you probably already know, we lack a language for talking about these things, making it hard to communicate methods and personal breakthroughs in self-manipulation. For example, how would one write a guide on relaxing ones body? Even my own breakthroughs and methods are lost at times. I can write them down, but future me can't always replicate them. So I might read "trust the universe" and get closer to a flow state, or forget exactly what I meant by that.
Interesting post, by the way!
Your inhibitions exist to protect you. At some point in your life, something conditioned that inhibition, and the brain now thinks that not having the inhibition is dangerous, so it won't let you dissolve it until it's convinced otherwise. You can probably turn down an inhibition since it's quite easy to argue that most inhibitions are exaggerated, and that's the idea with the "magic dial" in Book review: "Feeling Great" by David Burns
So I think the extent to which you can change your state of mind depends on how many restrictio... (read more)