This is a linkpost for https://www.gwern.net/Research-criticism
I'm too busy to do so today, but I'd appreciate it if someone wrote up a comment that distilled this down into summary.
Hmm. Maybe it does. I guess what I normal do when writing a distillation is check whether the abstract was sufficient.
(I have not yet read the post in full, but predicted that if I had, I'd want something that looked more like this as a distillation)
I generally want two things out of a distillation:
I call it decision leverage, for handiness, and looking for it changes casual conversation as well as analysis.