Comment Permalink

dbaupp13y40

Is there a particular reason that this forum doesn't use the "goes to top of page when posted on" mechanic that's used in many other popular forums?

Because (as far as I know) the back-end software doesn't support it, and implementing it is developer time. It would probably be easier to have an additional box on the right that points to the most recent post of each of "open_thread", "quotes", "media_thread" etc. tags.

(ETA: I've submitted an feature request)

See in context

40 Sticky threads?

by Anubhav

6th Feb 2012

1 min read

40

It annoys me that there's no way to sticky a thread in the discussion section.

Therefore, I propose creating an LW wiki page called "Stickies", where sticky-worthy threads would be linked to. Would that be acceptable?

These are the threads I'm planning to add:

the current Welcome to LW thread
the current MoR Discussion thread
the current Rationality Quotes thread (OK, they're posted in Main, but still...)
the current Open Thread
the current Media Thread
the current 'What are you working on?' thread

ETA: Following a tip-off by peaigr, I re-purposed the Special Threads wiki page for this. (The stickies are in the 'periodic threads' section.) Now if there were a way to make this page more conspicuous...

Meanwhile, dbaupp has submitted a feature request.

Site Meta

Frontpage

40

New Comment

11 comments, sorted by

top scoring

Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 8:28 PM

[-]calef13y70

Is there a particular reason that this forum doesn't use the "goes to top of page when posted on" mechanic that's used in many other popular forums?

I understand we're using the reddit-like architecture, but it seems (not that I have any sort of data to back it up) like it stifles discussion to let things drop off the front page as new things appear.

Or perhaps I'm just far more used to bump style forums.

[-]A1987dM13y50

Because it's not uncommon for people to comment on posts several years old, especially in Main. And the Recent Comments sidebar/page is good enough IMO.

[-]dbaupp13y40

Is there a particular reason that this forum doesn't use the "goes to top of page when posted on" mechanic that's used in many other popular forums?

(ETA: I've submitted an feature request)

[-]FiftyTwo13y00

It would be good to have something like reddit's 'hot' pages.

[-]WrongBot13y40

This is a great idea, and it would be even better if a link to that wiki page were added to the "Wiki | Sequences | About" section of the LW template.

[-][anonymous]13y20

It would look a bit cluttered.

[-]Alex_Altair13y20

I personally think we're under-utilizing the "Main | Discussion" side of the menu bar.

[-]curiousepic13y20

Also see this comment: http://lesswrong.com/lw/929/less_wrong_mentoring_network/5jnm?context=1#5jnm

[-]praxis13y00

Perhaps a different name? A good idea under any name, though, so don't let that hold you back, it can always be changed later.

[-][anonymous]13y40

Many of these threads are already tagged as 'community.' I would go with that.

Edit: There's also http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Special_threads, which has links to the 'quotes' and 'open_thread' tags, at least. I don't use the wiki much, so I'm not sure what the most useful way to proceed would be.

[-]Anubhav13y00

Fixed link.

Open threads aren't being tagged apparently... Last open thread tagged that way was in September 2011, the one before that in September 2010. Looks like I'll have to link manually.

Moderation Log