I think this is all correct, and we did the same thing with our kids. I think this is a really good approach in many ways.
One thing I've seen occasionally is adults misusing this in a deniable way. In the same way that someone can make a hurtful comment and then claim to be kidding, an adult can say something scary or confusing, when they knew or should have known that it was scary, and then claim that they didn't think anyone would believe it.
One example of that is "don't slip down the drain" to a small child taking a bath. Once they are old enough it's fine, but to a very small child it can be scary!
This post went in a different direction than I expected! I'm not sure if you're deliberately referencing what I thought you were going to talk about, lie-to-children: A simplification which is actually, factually, false, but which still builds an intuition in the right direction (not necessarily just aimed at children by the way).
I was wondering about that in relation to the conclusion: ' "am I leaving them with a false view" cleanly separates the harmful and beneficial cases.' It's sometimes tricky to know when building up an intuition is a "false view", or is a necessary step in the right direction. But I think in the goal all of this is congruent: the point of lie-to-children is to build the other party up and be loyal to them, not to be self serving.
I've just been reading The Left Hand of Darkness, and it's got this beautiful theme of betrayal and loyalty. Throughout the book characters are sometimes forced into situations where they have to break their promises in order to be loyal to their convictions. For example, stealing supplies so that they can survive and succeed in an important mission, or breaking a personal promise to fulfil a greater mission.
I feel like papa trolling is such a "betrayal", if you could call it that: A deliberate subversion which nevertheless supports and builds up the child. It's a good example of how these lines aren't always clear!
If kid me was exposed to my current views of honesty and perhaps cared less about authority's disapproval, there's a chance I would've made a point of spoiling Santa Claus and the Tooth Fairy on the grounds that it's good to remedy the effects of the nonconsensual lies - and I know kid me would've wanted to know when I was arguing with other kids about the details of Santa logistics[1]. I did do the whole annoying new atheist thing as a 12 year old. And, well, the reason I don't correct kids about Santa is just that it's not worth adults getting mad at me. If I had a child who took this position, I would just make sure they knew that it'd make many mad and otherwise not really stop them.
However, are you sure you shouldn't eat ice cream for every meal? Most people seem to be less saturated by ice cream than me. If I was like that, I wonder whether I'd wish I could have some ice cream with every meal. Clearly all the kids should elect me as dictator. ;-)
Especially since I'm pretty sure one of my friends in that argument secretly knew the truth.
I have very strong views on lying to kids: I think you both should and shouldn't do it. "Lying" covers a range, including saying things that hurt your kids and your relationship with them, and others that help them grow into an appropriately skeptical adult. The distinction is whether I'm leaving them believing something false.
For example, if my kids were asking for ice cream and I thought they'd already had too much sugar, I might be tempted to say "sorry, we're out of ice cream." Or if there's an ice cream truck and I think it's overpriced I might be tempted to say "sorry, I don't have any cash on me." But I'm not willing to say something false with the goal of causing them to believe something false. [1] In addition to that just being wrong:
It's important that the kids know that I'm fundamentally on their side, and lying for my convenience would burn trust when they'd eventually figure it out.
Kids are building a model of what is and is not ok, and "out of ice cream" and "no cash" lead them in the wrong direction.
Instead I would say "sorry, you already had candy" or "the ice cream costs more than I'm willing to pay" (which opens the door for them to offer to spend their allowance). Maybe they fuss, but they generally don't: I try hard to be predictable so this won't be much of a surprise to them, and they know I won't give in to extended fussing.
On the other hand, some false things I might say [2] about ice cream:
In all of these I'm saying a thing I think is false, but, very importantly, I'm not going to let the conversation end with them believing something false. Either they will realize it's false immediately, or I'll need to accept that my playfulness was miscalibrated to their perception and disclose the lie.
This builds the skill of thinking about whether things you hear are true. If I only ever said true things to them we wouldn't be able to practice that. This does need to be matched to their ability: a very little kid will push back on "you're made out of ice cream, and I'm going to eat you up!" but not "we can leave the ice cream out as long as we want, it won't melt."
It also functions as a good jumping off point. If I suggest they pour their ice cream on the floor when they're done with it, that lets me reinforce or explain good behavior. This could go different ways with different kids, with age being a large component. Thinking about how this might have gone with my kids:
Age 7:
Age 5 [3]:
Age 3:
Age 2:
Which does illustrate something important: you really do need to be a good judge of the kid you're interacting with. These depend on the kid knowing the actual rule well enough that you can play with it. I only want to say "let's juggle ice cream" to a kid who knows enough not to try, but if they do know then me being silly about it reinforces the "don't juggle ice cream" norm and signals that I trust them enough to know they wouldn't do it.
The final reason I say false things to kids is just that papa trolling is fun for both of us, as long as I don't do it too much. [4]
It is a bit weird to be both very strongly opposed to lying to kids and also say false things to them many times a day, but "am I leaving them with a false view" cleanly separates the harmful and beneficial cases.
[1] This means we don't tell the kids that Santa or the Tooth Fairy exist. But we do explain the overall situation, with how for some families it's a game the parents play with their kids, so that we don't have our kids going around spoiling it for other families.
[2] The first draft of this post had "everyone can have ice cream except Nora" but then I checked with her and it wasn't clear she would have understood it to be joking about unfairness. Then I asked her about "when you're done with your ice cream, put it down your sister's back" and she got it right away.
[3] After writing this post I tried it with Nora, age 5.4:
[4] I do some of this with adults as well, as a big part of my sense of humor. It's not a considered approach to building skepticism, just what comes naturally. I think some of this is from my upbringing, in a very "questioning is a form of respect "culture (influenced by both the Quaker and Jewish sides of the family).
Comment via: facebook, mastodon, bluesky