LESSWRONG
LW

MusicPractical
Personal Blog

9

Penny Whistle in E?

by jefftk
13th Mar 2025
jefftk
1 min read
1

9

MusicPractical
Personal Blog

9

Penny Whistle in E?
1npostavs
New Comment
1 comment, sorted by
top scoring
Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 6:40 AM
[-]npostavs6mo10

What about tuning the fiddle strings down 1 tone?

Reply
Moderation Log
More from jefftk
View more
Curated and popular this week
1Comments

Lily has been trying to raise money for her class by busking, but it's cold enough that I don't want to play violin. I've been playing penny whistle, warm inside my pennywhistle mitten (thanks Julia!) but a lot of the fiddle tunes Lily plays are hard to play on a D whistle. A D whistle is good for a lot of keys (D, Amix, Em, G, ...) but Lily knows a lot of tunes in A and even some in E. Ages ago I had a tiny whistle in A, but I lost it at some point, which was probably for the best since it's absurdly high.

What I'd really like, though, is a whistle in E. Just a little higher pitched than the D whistle, but good for playing in A and E. Except as far as I can tell no one is making these right now?

  • Tony Dixon E: out of stock
  • Susato High E: out of stock, also on the pricy side
  • Generation: now only lists Bb, C, D, Eb, F, G, though I'm pretty sure they used to have a chromatic lineup.

I did find a carbon fiber one for $330 and a brass one for $300, but while I'm sure these sound wonderful as whistles go, I'm not going to play this enough to be worth getting something fancy.

Comment via: facebook, mastodon, bluesky