Most of your predictions seem extremely reasonable, but your comment about car companies, in 2015, predicting they'd make self-driving cars by 2020, makes me question the sanity of anyone writing those announcements. It takes (and has taken for decades, this is the standard assumption for anyone doing automotive R&D or market research on the industry) 3-5 years to bring a car to production from the time you produce the first concept. Also, 2020 models come out in late 2019. So the only way any of those companies should have made that prediction in 2015 would be if they were ready to unveil a concept within the next couple of months, and believed that there would be literally no additional delays caused by technological or regulatory or supply chain challenges in bringing the first self-driving vehicles to market.
I wonder if asteroid mining advances will finally prod governments into developing defenses against Earth-bound asteroids. "Multiple private and foreign actors can direct big chunks of space rock at you, at will, and you won't find out until after they've done it" is so much more motivating than "Someday an asteroid could spontaneously wipe us all out."
On drug resistance: changes in medical practice about antibiotic use are important and I hope they continue, but I think the bigger shift is going to come from livestock production. Cellular agriculture would be great for that (probably), but in the meantime we're already finally starting to see serious investments in prebiotics, probiotics, vaccines, bacteriophage therapies, and other treatments and feed additives.
Subjectively, this year I've noticed a huge increase in new foods appearing in normal grocery stores - plant based meats being one example. These are often products that have exited for a while but are just now leaving specialty and higher end stores. I've been assuming it's not coincidence that this seemed to happen right in the middle of covid-induced supply chain disruptions (stores want to fill their shelves with something). I think that shaves a few years off my expected timeline for the shift away from conventional livestock.
Regarding the CRISPR babies, hasn't that already happened?
https://apnews.com/article/4997bb7aa36c45449b488e19ac83e86d
The prediction is (emphasis added)
At least one other CRISPR baby will be born by January 2030.
Is the article you linked mentioning a second one? (I doubt because I looked into it after that article was published, and even wrote a wiki page on it)
You missed the third baby announced as part of the trial:
Dr. He, 35, sent the scientific world into an uproar last year when he announced at a conference in Hong Kong that he had created the world’s first genetically edited babies — twin girls. On Monday, China’s state media said his work had resulted in a third genetically edited baby, who had been previously undisclosed...“He violated medical ethics, disrespected life and let three poor children bear the consequences, all for his fame and fortune,” one user wrote. “I think this punishment is too light.”
Author: Mati Roy | Created: 2020-01-11 | Updated: 2020-03-01 (Adjusted: 2020-11-07) | Published: 2020-11-07
Quality: Those are notes I took for my present and future selves; they weren’t taken with the purpose of informing others.
Importance: 3/10. I don’t think all those predictions are important / transformational. It’s likely not important for you to read this.
Epistemic status: My credences are already quantified for each prediction. But my predictions are not independent of each other. For example, shorter AI timelines could mean shorter timelines on all those predictions, and vice versa. I might also be miscalibrated on long-term predictions — I don’t have first hand experience with that having only been born recently.
Context: I wrote some predictions in January-Ferbruary 2020 (some with links to PredictionBook and Metaculus with the exact date available on those platforms). I hadn’t published it at the time because there were a bunch of other topics I wanted to make predictions on. They are mostly predictions made on a 10-100 years time horizon.
Value to me: Making this research was much more time consuming than I thought. It was an interesting exercise, and will likely be interesting to check back on those predictions in the future. Here’s how I felt going down this rabbit hole.
Medium: Ideally, I would like a prediction platform where I could post my comments and predictions on public questions, like Metaculus, but with the additional option of having a personal public page automatically aggregating all my predictions and comments, similar to what I did here.
Cellular agriculture
Why care?
A reduced population of farmed animals would also likely reduce the risk of pandemics.
It would also likely allow us to create meat for cheaper.
It might also provide a more robust food supply.
It would also allow us to create healthier meat, with less contaminants.
It would also allow us to create a wider range of food, such as synthesizing new forms of meat.
It might also make it easier to sustain human life on other celestial bodies.
Predictions
85%: Meat and/or dairy products from cellular agriculture will be commercially available by January 1st, 2030. (PredictionBook)
75%: A company with its main activity being cultured meat and/or dairy products will be valued at >= 1bn 2020USD by January 1st, 2030. (PredictionBook)
52%: The U.S. plant-based and cultured-based retail market will be worth more than 9bn 2020USD throughout 2029. (PredictionBook)
Predictions using Elicit: https://elicit.ought.org/builder/nUEGbEPgb (h/t Jungwon)
Notes
2020-01-22: Memphis Meats receives 161 million USD in its Series B fundraising, more than the total investment in cultivated meat companies so far which was of 155 million USD. (source)
Organization: https://www.cellag.org/work/project-cmf/
Investment trends: https://www.gfi.org/industry
Other predictions: Clean meat series, Alt-meat party
Timeline: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_cellular_agriculture
More info: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cellular_agriculture
Quantum computers
Why care?
(source)
Applications: http://www.theory.caltech.edu/~preskill/talks/Preskill-Q2B-2019.pdf
Predictions
I put ~15% probability that noisy intermediate-scale quantum will solve at least one useful problem and/or be economically viable by January 1st, 2030. I’m not sure how to properly operationalize this either. Ex. of applications: certified randomness.
Notes
Quantum supremacy (ie. being able to do something which we can’t do with classical computers) is a spectrum, but we’re currently transitioning to it. (Metaculus)
I’m not sure how to operationalize this; maybe the ratio of energy it takes for a classical computer to solve the same problem as a quantum computer? Here’s another idea: “Will it cost less than $1000 to calculate the private key of a 2048-bit RSA public key in 2030?” (Metaculus).
Richard Haughton says:
But I couldn’t find any graphs of the maximum quantum volume achieved over time.
It would also be nice to operationalize how much noise a quantum computer has.
John Preskill says:
Scott Aaronson:
Note: It could be economically viable, yet not economically benefitial (ex.: if people only buy quantum defenses to secure themselves against quantum attacks).
China’s National Laboratory for Quantum Information Sciences is a US$10 billion project due to open in 2020. (source). Europe’s Quantum Technology Flagship is a €1 billion euros project that opened in 2016. There are ~7000 researchers publishing ~8,500 articles per year [as of 2014] (source).
Longest quantum entanglement distance: February 2020 record: 50 km; previous record was 1.3 km (source).
Investment trends: https://www.cbinsights.com/research/report/quantum-computing/
Popularity trends: https://www.cbinsights.com/research/quantum-computing-startup-ecosystem/
Other trends: https://quantumcomputingtech.blogspot.com/2018/02/quantum-computer-investing.html
Other predictions: Metaculus
Timeline: https://timelines.issarice.com/wiki/Timeline_of_Quantum_Computing
More info: https://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/
Nuclear fusion
Why care?
Pros
Economic prosperity of having cheap and abundant energy. Energy is a $8.5 trillion energy industry.
Cons
Also see: Pure fusion weapon — Wikipedia
Predictions
When will the fusion energy gain factor of a fusion reactor reach a Q >= 1? — 75% before 2044
When will a fusion reactor reach ignition? — 50% before before 2051
When will a nuclear fusion reactor hit an economic breakeven? — 50% before 2057
Other
Will radical new "low-energy nuclear reaction" technologies prove effective before 2019?
Will General Fusion [meet] its plasma temperature targets by mid-2020?
When will the first 100 Megawatt fusion-based electrical generation facility come into service?
A revival of interest in muon-catalyzed fusion?
Notes
The JET (Joint European Torus) is the world’s largest operational magnetically confined palsma physics experiment. It started its operation in 1983. (source)
ITER is a large international project to build a magnetic confinement plamaphysics experiment 10 timers bigger than the current biggest. The project was officially initiated in 1988. The building costs were over US$14 billion by June 2015, and the construction of the facility is expected to be completed in 2025. Initial plasma experiments are scheduled to begin in 2025, with full deuterium-tritium fusion experiments starting in 2035. Since the 1950, more than 100 fusion reactors have been built. (source)
DEMO, ITER’s successor, is planned to be constructed in 2024-2033, and have a first phase of operation in 2033-2038. After which, it would be expanded and updated, with the second phase of operation starting in 2040. In 2012, the roadmap aimed to have an electricity generation demonstration in 2048. (source)
PROTO, DEMO’s successor, is planned for after 2050. PROTO would act as a prototype power station demonstrating electricity generation on a commercial basis. (source)
From fusion energy gain factor:
[...]
(source)
Other projects include: Wendelstein 7-X, HiPER, National Ignition Facility.
Graph of US investment: https://i.huffpost.com/gen/2470392/original.jpg
Projection for leading fusion projects: https://2oqz471sa19h3vbwa53m33yj-wpengine.netdna-ssl.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/fusion-timeline.jpg
Kurzgesagt video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mZsaaturR6E
Timeline: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_nuclear_fusion
Space mining
Why care?
Although part of the wealth is at current market value, which would drop a lot with a higher offer.
This could prove very useful if we develop viable nuclear fusion.
Predictions
When will space mining reach profitability?
50%: Space mining will be profitable before 2090, conditional on no existential catastrophe or win
Notes
More info: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asteroid_mining
Self-driving cars
Why care?
Safety
Cost
(source)
(source)
Car owners will be able to put their cars to work as a taxi when they aren’t using it. In fact, most people won’t need to own a car because of that.
Given that fleets of self-driving cars are better coordinated, traffic will also be reduced.
Given that on-demand cars will be as cheap as owning a car, and that these cars will be safe, smaller cars (for 1 or 2 passengers) will make sense.
Environment
This added efficiency will also result in less cars being built and less greenhouse gases per distance.
Predictions
My predictions
50% Level 3 autonomous cars will be commercially available by 2030. (PredictionBook)
50% Level 4 autonomous cars will be commercially available by 2036. (PredictionBook)
50% Level 5 autonomous cars will be commercially available by 2042. (PredictionBook)
50% Level 5 self-driving air vehicles will be available by 2030. (PredictionBook)
Clarification: Needs to be available for commercial use on public roads in at least one city (not just on the highway).
Pending
When will Level 3 self-driving cars be available commercially? (Metaculus)
When will Level 4 self-driving cars be commecially available commercially? (Metaculus)
When will Level 5 self-driving cars be available commercially? (Metaculus)
Other
In what year will half of new cars sold in the US be fully autonomous? (Metaculus)
Past prediction
Metrics
(source; discussion)
February 2020 notes
R&D
Features
Distance
(source)
Accidents
(source)
Law
(source)
Investments
2014: $167 million
2017: #3 billion
First 3 quarters of 2018: $4.2 billion
(CB Insights)
Total so far [early 2020]: at least $16 billion (source)
Other notes
History: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_self-driving_cars
More info: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-driving_car
Fully artificial kidney
Why care?
Predictions
50% Fully artificial kidneys will be publicly available by 2042. (PredictionBook)
Notes
(source)
Related: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expanded_access
More info: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artificial_kidney
Global population
8.5 million people in 2030 (source)
50% CI: 8.3-8.7
More info: https://ourworldindata.org/world-population-growth
Male birth control pill
Predictions
50% A male birth control pill will be commercially available in the US or EU by 2045. (PredictionBook)
Other
(source)
More information: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Male_contraceptive#Research
Man mission to Mars
63%: Will Mars have a permanent population of 10,000 before the Moon does?
1%: Will NASA land people on Mars prior to 2030?
Will SpaceX land people on Mars prior to 2030?
Deepest hole
Predictions
50% A hole will be drilled down to Earth's mantle by 2090. (PredictionBook)
More info: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smithsonian-institution/ask-smithsonian-whats-deepest-hole-ever-dug-180954349/
Cryptocurrencies
24%: Bitcoins thought to belong to Satoshi Nakamoto will be spent by 2075-04-05. (PredictionBook; Metaculus)
Notes without predictions
Gene editing
Operationalisation
At least one other CRISPR baby will be born by January 2030.
Notes
**Timeline: **https://timelines.issarice.com/wiki/Timeline_of_genetic_engineering_in_humans
Geothermal power
Electric cars
The main battery technology used to be lead-acid, then came alkaline, then nickel-cadmium, and now lithium-ion in many different chemical configurations. In the future, we expect solid-state batteries, and perhaps boxes with nanoscale flywheels, flow batteries, or supercapacitators.
Bloomberg expects 1,000% (a tenfold) growth between now and 2025, reaching 11% market share for BEVs in the total private vehicle (PV) market by then. It then anticipates another 170% growth from 2025 to about 30% in 2030. That is followed by only 80% growth from 2030 to reach a 55% market share in 2040. Why Bloomberg expects the growth curve to flatten when the products get better and cheaper instead of following the normal S-curve is not discussed.
Battery development is on a technology curve. Characteristics of this curve are a ~14% decline in price ($/kWh) and a 6% increase in density (kWh/kg). Combined with power electronics, battery and motor management computers, motors, and gears, a combined decrease of 7% per year is used.
Environmental concerns call for increasingly stricter exhaust standards, making internal combustion engines and exhaust-treating systems more expensive, resulting in an expected 3% yearly increase.
Drug resistance
Operationalisations
Notes
I’m basing this prediction on two high-level reports released last year: one from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the other from the United Nations. The reports presented some pretty terrifying findings: Resistance to second- and third-line antibiotics (often the last lines of defense) is projected to almost double between 2005 and 2030. If we don’t make a radical change now, drug-resistant diseases could kill 10 million people a year by 2050 — up from 700,000 a year now.
(https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2020/1/13/21055740/trump-reelection-biden-nomination-brexit-2020-predictions)
Facial recognition
To be clear, I’m talking about a ban that applies to city departments like police; I think outright bans that would also cover businesses, individuals, and federal agencies are way less likely.
(source)
Climate change
Future of bets
Prediction on prediction platforms on Foretold
Brain-reading
Notable players: Facebook, Microsoft, Neuralink (source), Nissan (source)
Notable early applications: controller for a VR headset; computer navigation for handicapped people
Metrics: words per minute typed; vocabulary it can detects + accuracy
Currently: In 2013, it was possible to identify which single image was being seen from a set of 120. (source)
More info: Brain-reading — Wikipedia; Neuralink — WaitButWhy
Other topics I was interested in predicting
Technology / politics
Internet speed
Fuel cells cars
Antimatter production
Space elevators
Heat resistant material
3D printed building (note: Dubai has built the world's largest 3D printed building)
Small nuclear reactor (note: Pentagon awards contracts to design mobile nuclear reactor — skimmed)
Daily imaging of Earth (see: Planet Labs, Inc.)
Military drones
Remote work: Telehealth
Smart cities; private cities (note: Smart City Will Privately- Owned Towns Drive the Development of Smart Cities? — not read)
Holography (Wikipedia)
Vaccine without needles (not read)
Geothermal energy
Energy consumption
Longevity
Advance autocomplete (ex.: drawing)
Taste viewer
Governance
FDA average years to approve drug
Assisted suicide
Population
World population growth
Fertility rate
Life expectancy
Population density
Most populous cities
Genetically modified animals (operationalisation: If DNA alterations continue to require FDA approval by default, how many intentionally genomic DNA altered animals will be determined as safe to eat, by the end of July 2025? ; Metaculus)
Emergency called automatically
Fintech
Real Estate Sales To Take Place Entirely Online In A Seamless Way
Tokenization And Global Liquidity
Physical money doesn’t exist in the US anymore
More money in proptech
Porn
Porn with created from images of people of your choices
Porn generated by AI based on keywords of your choice
Reinforcement learning to generate porn tailored to your preference
Other
Spoken languages,
North Korea and South Korea unification (PredictionBook)
Eco-economic decoupling
Veganism (Metaculus)