LESSWRONG
LW

Nominated Posts for the 2019 Review

Posts need at least 2 nominations to continue into the Review Phase.
Nominate posts that you have personally found useful and important.
Sort by: fewest nominations
749

2019 Review Discussion

In My Culture
77
Duncan Sabien (Inactive)
7y
This is a linkpost for https://medium.com/@ThingMaker/in-my-culture-29c6464072b2

This is a linkpost for https://medium.com/@ThingMaker/in-my-culture-29c6464072b2 

One of my colleagues has a neat little trick.

Sometimes, in the middle of a conversation—especially if things are heated or tense or confusing—they’ll pause, and they’ll say something like:

“I’m sorry, but—look. In my culture…”

…and then they’ll go on to explain something that one might easily mistake for a rule, or a request, or the enforcement of a social norm, but which is actually (as far as I can tell) just a statement about the version of the world they carry around inside their head.

Because none of us quite have the same culture, after all. We all differ in different ways from the Basic Package—even those of us who’ve lived in the same towns, gone to the same schools, worked in the same...

(Continue Reading - 6924 more words)
2homosapien9710d
I appreciate that this framing can have positive impact on individual interactions, and can be useful in expanding what kinds of cultural norms might be better than one's current ones. It would be pretty valuable to me to be able to specify "no pressure, I prefer to interact this way". Nevertheless, I would be pretty unhappy if personalization of culture became accepted as part of the broader culture, and I think one of my objections to it is generally applicable.   If everyone did this, it would impose large costs on people with bad memories (like myself), and even on people with normal memories. Despite the low-stakes phrasing, norm personalization is a bit like having a very long name--consistent failures to remember, or refusal to try to remember, provides more bits in the "I don't really care about you" signal, but most people will not adjust the strength of signal based on how costly remembering is for the other party (I only have anecdata to support this claim). Even people who currently have a socially-sufficient memory could find themselves unpleasantly surprised by accidentally sending the signal "I don't care about you" to conversational partners when hitting a previously non-limiting constraint. Diplomats can do this successfully with a single other culture, but even they might struggle to remember a different culture for everyone they know. One possible effect of this is a soft cap on the number of people you can successfully interact with based on your available memory--right now, this is bounded over long time scales by how many face+name pairs you can remember, and in the short term by how easy it is to memorize someone's name while talking to them. As an example, I have a colleague who has trouble learning non-WASP names, and I think it reduces his success in interacting with people who have those names. 
Duncan Sabien (Inactive)9d31

I think there's a conflation here between "the internal experience of the emotion of caring" and "the act of caring, visible to external observers."

I think you're saying "I might take actions that look like not-caring, due to constraints like memory, and I don't want this to be misconstrued as not having the internal experience of caring," but I think that ultimately if one has ... akrasiatic caring? ... this doesn't matter.  I think that whether it's down to unfortunate memory constraints or like deliberate callousness, what usually carries weight is... (read more)

Reply
Load More
49How common is it for one entity to have a 3+ year technological lead on its nearest competitor?
QΩ
Daniel Kokotajlo
6y
QΩ
20
1 • 0
122What Comes After Epistemic Spot Checks?
Elizabeth
6y
9
1 • 0
52"The Bitter Lesson", an article about compute vs human knowledge in AI
the gears to ascension
6y
14
1 • 0
66Combat vs Nurture & Meta-Contrarianism
abramdemski
7y
12
1 • 0
91What I've Learned From My Parents' Arranged Marriage
squidious
6y
16
1 • 0
70Reneging prosocially by Duncan Sabien
philip_b
6y
5
1 • 0
65AGI will drastically increase economies of scale
Ω
Wei Dai
6y
Ω
26
1 • 0
92Reframing the evolutionary benefit of sex
paulfchristiano
6y
21
1 • 0
101The LessWrong 2018 Review
Raemon
6y
91
1 • 0
67Separation of Concerns
abramdemski
6y
30
1 • 0
32Calibrating With Cards
[anonymous]6y
3
1 • 0
148Integrating disagreeing subagents
Kaj_Sotala
6y
15
1 • 0
54Perfect Competition
Zvi
6y
29
1 • 0
113CO2 Stripper Postmortem Thoughts
Diffractor
6y
37
1 • 0
170Jeff Hawkins on neuromorphic AGI within 20 years
Steven Byrnes
6y
24
1 • 0
95Naked mole-rats: A case study in biological weirdness
eukaryote
6y
14
1 • 0
61Book Review: Why Are The Prices So Damn High?
sarahconstantin
6y
7
1 • 0
82Misconceptions about continuous takeoff
Ω
Matthew Barnett
6y
Ω
38
1 • 0
44Self-consciousness wants to make everything about itself
jessicata
6y
70
1 • 0
165The Commitment Races problem
Ω
Daniel Kokotajlo
6y
Ω
56
1 • 0
533 Cultural Infrastructure Ideas from MAPLE
Unreal
6y
15
1 • 0
73Imperfect Competition
Zvi
6y
8
1 • 0
74Moral Mazes and Short Termism
Zvi
6y
21
1 • 0
87Two explanations for variation in human abilities
Matthew Barnett
6y
28
2 • 1
232Mistakes with Conservation of Expected Evidence
abramdemski
6y
29
2 • 1
167The Schelling Choice is "Rabbit", not "Stag"
Raemon
6y
52
2 • 3
185human psycholinguists: a critical appraisal
nostalgebraist
6y
60
2 • 2
180Selection vs Control
Ω
abramdemski
6y
Ω
27
2 • 2
87Neural Annealing: Toward a Neural Theory of Everything (crosspost)
Michael Edward Johnson
6y
29
2 • 3
119The Hard Work of Translation (Buddhism)
romeostevensit
6y
139
2 • 3
72Classifying specification problems as variants of Goodhart's Law
Ω
Vika
6y
Ω
5
2 • 1
82Approval Extraction Advertised as Production
Benquo
6y
40
2 • 3
135Propagating Facts into Aesthetics
Raemon
6y
38
2 • 1
87Bioinfohazards
Spiracular
6y
14
2 • 2
79How Much is Your Time Worth?
lynettebye
6y
22
2 • 1
87But exactly how complex and fragile?
Ω
KatjaGrace
6y
Ω
32
2 • 1
61Dishonest Update Reporting
Zvi
6y
27
2 • 2
236Rest Days vs Recovery Days
Unreal
6y
36
2 • 1
60Dual Wielding
Zvi
6y
23
2 • 3
173Integrity and accountability are core parts of rationality
habryka
6y
68
2 • 1
97Reframing Impact
Ω
TurnTrout
6y
Ω
15
2 • 1
55Megaproject management
ryan_b
7y
11
2 • 1
181Book Summary: Consciousness and the Brain
Kaj_Sotala
7y
20
2 • 1
122Reframing Superintelligence: Comprehensive AI Services as General Intelligence
Ω
Rohin Shah
7y
Ω
77
2 • 2
208Chris Olah’s views on AGI safety
Ω
evhub
6y
Ω
40
2 • 2
221Debate on Instrumental Convergence between LeCun, Russell, Bengio, Zador, and More
Ω
Ben Pace
6y
Ω
61
2 • 2
103Total horse takeover
KatjaGrace
6y
14
2 • 1
167Make more land
jefftk
6y
36
2 • 5
70What determines the balance between intelligence signaling and virtue signaling?
Q
Wei Dai, Jacob Falkovich
6y
Q
37
2 • 0
107Gradient hacking
Ω
evhub
6y
Ω
39
2 • 2
Load More (50/143)